Behind Carrie Underwood’s Country Glamour Lies an Unexpected Obsession: The 3 Classic Horror Franchises She Watches on Repeat

Country music superstar Carrie Underwood may be celebrated for powerhouse anthems and pristine stage presence, but her personal entertainment taste leans heavily into the dark, eerie, and downright terrifying.

During “Hollywood Week” on season 23 of American Idol, the Grammy-winning judge caught viewers and contestants completely off guard when asked to name her top three favorite films of all time. Rather than naming feel-good musical classics or heart-wrenching southern dramas, Underwood delivered an unapologetic rundown of vintage slasher lore and sci-fi dread.

Her definitive picks immediately redefined how millions view the country icon.

“Probably ‘Halloween,’ ‘A Nightmare on Elm Street;’ I’ve seen all of them. The ‘Alien’ franchises.”

The unfiltered admission instantly blew up among the show’s faithful audience, who had long associated the “Before He Cheats” vocalist exclusively with mainstream country traditions.

Inside Underwood’s High-Octane and Spooky Taste

The contestant who originally prompted the film question admitted what many casual fans were thinking in real time: “I really would not have guessed this from you.”

Fellow judge Luke Bryan did not miss the chance to react either. Bryan joked on camera that Underwood possessed a hidden “dark side,” adding with a laugh:

“I’m scared to sit by her at this point.”

Carrie Underwood

Yet anyone who closely tracks Underwood’s artistic roots knows her creative interests stretch far beyond Nashville’s standard borders.

During an audition round, she stunned spectators by instantly identifying every word to Korn’s heavy-metal anthem “Freak on a Leash.” Later, she shook festival-goers by taking the stage at Iowa’s Velocity Festival to belt out Limp Bizkit’s 1999 nu-metal hit “Break Stuff.”

The Fan Perception vs. The Reality

A widespread public myth assumes country superstars strictly consume acoustic ballads and family-friendly sitcoms in their off hours.

Underwood consistently disproves that stereotype. From chest-pounding 1990s hard rock to grueling survival-horror cinema, her personal pop-culture rotation reflects genuine fan enthusiasm rather than a carefully curated public persona.

A Massive Family Halloween Tradition

Underwood’s passion for eerie aesthetics extends straight into her personal life every October.

The singer has made elaborate family dress-up an annual ritual alongside her husband, former professional hockey player Mike Fisher, and their two sons, Isaiah and Jacob.

Past holidays have showcased creative group ensembles, ranging from humorous concepts to classic storybook characters:

• The Trophy Hunt: Fisher suited up as a deer hunter while Underwood joined in matching deer gear.
• Whimsical Characters: Underwood donned a bright pink Care Bears onesie while Fisher showed off a long black wig and mustache.
• Whoville Duo: Her eldest son Isaiah went all out as the Grinch, paired with younger brother Jacob as the faithful canine sidekick, Max.
• Four-Legged Accents: Underwood even outfitted her two pet dogs in tiny cowboy getups to complete the household holiday celebration.

Throwback photos prove the seasonal enthusiasm started early for the singer, who previously showed fans childhood snapshots of herself in full rabbit gear clutching a jack-o’-lantern bucket.

💬 Finding out that one of country music’s biggest stars prefers Freddy Krueger and Xenomorphs over rom-coms makes her even more relatable to dedicated horror lovers.

✨ Drop your thoughts in the comments below: Which of Carrie Underwood’s top three horror choices is your absolute favorite?

📱 Share this story with fellow music and movie fans to see if they can match her spooky season playlist.